Skip to content
231,188 profiles ranked

1876 United States presidential election: Rutherford B. Hayes wins

What kind of moment: History, Election

1876 United States presidential election: Rutherford B. Hayes wins

When
7 November 1876
Where
United States
Electoral College margin
Hayes won 185-184

On November 7, 1876, Americans elected Republican Rutherford B. Hayes as president in one of the most contentious contests in U.S. history. Hayes defeated Democrat Samuel J. Tilden in a race so close it hinged on disputed electoral votes from three Southern states, triggering a constitutional crisis that wouldn't be resolved until March 1877 - and fundamentally reshaping the country's approach to Reconstruction.

The 1876 election fracture exposed the fragility of American democratic institutions during Reconstruction. The compromise that ultimately seated Hayes - removing federal troops from the South in exchange for Republican victory - effectively ended Reconstruction and initiated nearly a century of Jim Crow rule across the former Confederacy.

In numbers

Disputed electoral votes
20 (from Florida, Louisiana, and South Carolina)
Electoral College margin
Hayes won 185-184
Resolving body
Electoral Commission (15 members)

The result

Seats, change and vote share as the results table of 1876 United States presidential election gives them. No readers here: daily readers are counted from 2015 on.

  1. Republican PartyRutherford B. Hayes47.9% seats
  2. Democratic PartySamuel J. Tilden50.9% seats

How it unfolded

  1. Election Day

    Americans vote in a highly polarized election between Republican Rutherford B. Hayes and Democrat Samuel J. Tilden. Early returns suggest a Tilden victory, but results from Florida, Louisiana, South Carolina, and Oregon remain uncertain.

  2. Recount demands

    Both parties claim victory and demand recounts in disputed states. Republican operatives move to South Carolina and Florida to oversee counting efforts; Democratic representatives do the same.

  3. Compromise of 1877

  4. Hayes declared winner

    Congress certifies Hayes as president-elect after the filibuster breaks. Hayes is inaugurated two days later without significant incident.

  5. Last troops withdrawn

    Federal troops depart South Carolina, the final state occupied since Reconstruction began. The withdrawal marks the formal end of Reconstruction and opens the door to rapid disenfranchisement of Black voters.

  6. What followed

    1877: Compromise of 1877

  7. What followed

    1877: Creation of Electoral Commission

  8. What followed

    1877: Restoration of Southern Democratic power

Where it sits in their lives

  1. Ulysses S. Grant1822 to 188554
  2. Rutherford B. Hayes1822 to 189354
  3. Samuel J. Tilden1814 to 188662
  4. Peter Cooper1791 to 188385
  • Their age at this moment
  • Their other moments in history
More about this election